I can already see readers of this column rolling their eyes.
“There he goes again, carrying on about the grid!”
It’s a big, complicated and frankly expensive issue that we can’t keep punting on.
The New York Independent System Operator’s draft reliability report projects a statewide electricity supply shortfall beginning in 2033 under its base assumptions. The report says the solutions require substantial time for development, approvals, permitting and construction.
We need to solve the problem now and stop pretending everything will be fine.
I don’t think it’s realistic to believe that we’re not going to see significant data center development over the next several years with the other investments around AI continuing. Especially on the economic development and higher education fronts.
But it shouldn’t be a this-or-that proposition. We’re pinning too much of our energy debate on something that hasn’t even been built yet. It’s silly.
If we’re already seeing problems keeping the power on, then our problems are going to continue even if we don’t build a single additional data center in the state.
Take what I’d call “blue sky outages,” where the weather is perfect, and there’s a power outage.
There was one in Ontario County in May that FingerLakes1.com and other newsrooms covered. More than 17,000 RG&E customers lost power during calm weather, and Canandaigua schools opened on a two-hour delay. RG&E later said an equipment issue at its Manchester substation caused it.
There were also outages on consecutive mornings this week in Rochester. More than 1,100 customers lost power each morning, with outages concentrated around Park and East avenues. The causes remained unknown as of writing this column.
It feels like the same protocol: The power company says it’s investigating, power comes back, and we move on. Sometimes we get an explanation, as we did in Ontario County. But saying equipment failed doesn’t tell us why it failed or whether the underlying problem has been fixed.
The outage might just mean inconvenience. But if this kind of stuff keeps happening, it poses real quality-of-life concerns.
Do you want to live somewhere where the power just randomly goes out on sunny days?
Those outages don’t establish that we don’t have enough energy. But from a general grid reliability perspective, they’re questions the power companies need to answer.
And there’s more here than my frustration.
A state audit released in May 2025 found that Avangrid underspent on asset management, contributing to NYSEG’s poor electric reliability performance. It also found that executive incentive payouts weren’t based on attaining goals specific to NYSEG and RG&E.
To me, that gets to the responsibility these companies have been allowed to avoid through policy and regulation.
They point to things like vegetation management as a major effort of theirs. And that’s great. But it’s not the solution to the problem anyone is looking for when equipment fails and whole communities lose service.
The power companies need to invest money into the system to get it up to speed and meet today’s needs. And tomorrow’s.
I think the companies that manage electricity should be forced to produce a five- and 10-year plan that actually meets the needs of residents and the state at large.
They already file plans. NYSEG and RG&E’s April five-year capital plan proposes approximately $13.7 billion for 2026 through 2030, including $12.3 billion for electric and generation systems. That includes multiple kinds of investment, not just repairs.
It’s a cartoonishly large number, and I think everyone involved needs to see and hear it.
The layperson needs to see it as a form of accountability and understanding that they will have to shoulder some cost. But the power companies need to be accountable for what they’ve allowed on their watch.
The plans are only one step, though.
The state should essentially put the power companies on probation. Get the grid up to the standards residents need within a decade, with clear requirements along the way, or face losing ownership of the assets serving those communities.
Create a process that allows communities to acquire those assets if the companies can’t meet their obligations. Make that a real consequence.
For years, I’ve listened and talked to experts who’ve told me that a public utility isn’t possible because of the expense around acquiring the stuff from the power companies.
And on paper, the assets are worth a lot.
But if the utilities also have billions in required work to be done over the next decade, what’s the full cost of keeping things the way they are?
Are these companies and their assets really worth what has been described before if they also need to spend billions over the next decade to get the system where it needs to be?
I’m not suggesting we can simply subtract every dollar of future investment from the purchase price. I’m asking why the expense of acquiring the system seems to end the conversation, while the expense of continuing under the current model doesn’t.
Sure, these companies exist to make money for their owners. But they also have a responsibility to provide reliable electricity.
The power companies need to deal with the problem. And if, God forbid, they say, “Sorry, we don’t have the money,” then, to them, I would politely say: Your business model sucks and is completely broken. Better put your company up for sale.
The status quo, or just waiting for the utility to do right on its own, seems well past its expiration date.
This isn’t a question of what kind of development is appropriate or not. We need a system that serves the people who already live here and can handle what comes next.
The utilities need to be held accountable. Not just given permission to pass the cost of their failures on to customers.
We need to solve the problem now and stop pretending everything will be fine.




